article finance

refused by my own credit scoring system!

My wife and I recently purchased a new car. After much looking around on the market and test driving and the like we decided to purchase a vehicle through a company that I had previously worked for.

I agreed to purchasing the car on 0% finance and was promptly taken to a private room to go through their credit searching system. No one was as surprised as me to discover that the credit searching system I had worked on 10 years previously, at the finance arm of the company, was still functioning and was about to credit check me!

There was a brief moment when I had to cast my mind back to make sure that I hadn’t left any ‘testing’ back doors in the application that I might trigger if I was to apply but then I remembered that I had not because I had a feeling that one day it might come back to haunt me. Relieved about this I settled down to the long drawn out question and answer process that is credit scoring in the UK. But then something strange happened (room spins) and a whole lot of unpleasant details about car finance and the credit scoring system “The UNDERWRITER” came back to me.

It seems that the rules for credit scoring are actually quite complex. I would expect that every credit organisation would have its own set of rules and in the UK there are a couple such agencies I think. The credit providers undertake to update the credit scoring system and hence any credit you ever had is known to them and they can use that information to assess your application.

Therefore it makes sense that if you’re applying for credit the following needs to be taken into consideration:

  • Have you ever had credit? Some people are surprised that if they’ve never had credit then they must be credit ‘worthy’ because they’ve demonstrated some sort of fiscal prudence. However this is not really the case. The truth is that if you’ve had credit you’ve got a track record and it’s the track record that matters. That isn’t to say that no track record is bad it just doesn’t give you as many points as having one, which might ultimately affect how much you can borrow. Now if that track record shows missed mortgage payments or late credit card payments then this doesn’t help your score either.
  • Where do you live? You may have noticed you have to provide previous addresses and bank details for the last 3 years. If you’re anything like me this can be tedious. But there’s also a catch. Credit scores can be based by address and not name. I think in the US where everything is controlled by social security number this doesn’t apply, but in the UK that form of ID is not required to get credit. Now I agree you are not ‘where you live’ but if there are people who lived at your address who had bad credit that’s going to reflect on you. To all intents and purposes you’re in the same socio-economic group as the previous tenant of your previous addresses. Needless to say if you have any CCJs against you at an address you may as well move because almost no-one is going to want to lend to you at a good rate. But other than that your address says a lot more about you than you might at first think and the credit scoring people care about it.
  • Do you vote?This is the one that annoys me the most. It annoys me because I move around a lot and in the UK you don’t have to be on the electoral register and you don’t have to vote. But the electoral register has important information about you that can’t be faked and a lot of credit agencies will flat-out refuse anyone who isn’t on the electoral register. This can often be a way for people with bad credit to help themselves out, if your parents still live in the family home you could ‘move’ back in on paper by redirecting electoral roll/credit card/bank statements back to that address whilst you stay in the bad address. Effectively using their good standing (if they have one!) to improve your own. After a while you could use this as your primary address for credit and take it from there. However, since this is obtaining goods or services by deception it probably constitutes fraud and is not recommended since fraud carries a hefty penalty in the UK.
  • Are you looking for a lot of credit?Of course you are, but the more you look the lower your score gets. This makes sense on some level because if you start looking for a lot of money all of a sudden things can’t be good with you. This was demonstrated to me when we finally put the “UNDERWRITER” live and ran a couple of searches on my friend’s father to make sure that it was all connected up and working. We’d used him as a test case in our non-updating test system before we put the system live. Someone wanted to verify that all was good and over zealously issued 5 or so credit requests in a minute and my friends father’s credit rating went from hero to zero. Suffice to say credit searching without the intent of acquiring credit is illegal and we had some explaining to do.

Back to the story (room stops spinning). I met the critieria: I’d had a stable bank and address for 3 years, I paid my mortgage and credit cards on time, I was on the electoral register and I smelt of roses. Nothing could go wrong.

My own credit scoring system referred me! Now that’s not the same as being declined, it means that the computer wasn’t authorised to complete the scoring on its own and a human needed to look at it. There is a reason for this too. Some finance deals (0% ones being an example) are of limited value to the underwriter. They want to take extra care that they’re not issuing ‘risky’ finance on a 0% deal because the time-value of money means that they won’t be compensated for it.

Suffice to say a few days later someone looked at my ‘deal’ and issued it and I got the car. Sweet. It was especially sweet that the system that I helped write 10 years ago was still functioning. Which shows I can’t be all that bad at this software malarkey. YMMV 🙂

One reply on “refused by my own credit scoring system!”

Comments are closed.